Viewing Thread:
"Who would win in a fight between..."

The idea is to post the names of 2 different people and we debate who would win in a fight between them. Would also help to put where the person is from (ie.Film, Book, Computer Game etc.). Simple.

I'll start.

Leonidus (300) vs Aragorn (Lord of the Rings)

Good to see this has taken off quite well :)

Next one.

Neo (The Matrix) vs The Hulk (The Incredible Hulk)

Yarrr wrote:
> Hmm, it would be an epic battle... but they'd surely run out of
> arrows?
>
> Robin Hood is my bet, though not Russell Crowe's version.

I agree, Kevin Costner's depiction made Robin Hood look 'well tough!'

Though if you mean disney's robin hood - the fox - then he would surely win any battle. He would just be too cunning!

Legolas would blatantly win I think but you try and think of another legendary archer type :S

Oops, posted on my test pirate account.

Hmm, it would be an epic battle... but they'd surely run out of arrows?

Robin Hood is my bet, though not Russell Crowe's version.

Legolas - quicker, elf and cooler lol

Leonidas I think, in melee. The sheer ferocity and power (not to mention the fact that he was thought to be a foot taller) would be too much for Aragorn.

However you have to take into account the magical aspects. Aragorn would have better shield and sword, along with mythril armour. So on that account it might be closer.

Aragorn is far more intelligent though, having fought many foes who are better than him/ stronger/bigger. In reality Aragorn would not stand toe to toe with him and would retreat and use his ranger skills to pick him off with arrows. Let's not forget he was a ranger, with legendary skills in both stealth and range.

So all in all Aragorn would do him like a kipper.

Next bout
Legolas (LOTR) vs. Robin Hood :S

He fought a wolf - but Aragon would not be able to use the Army of the Dead, he used it to free Gondor and then set them to rest. So they cant be used anymore.

He is quicker than Leonidas (cant spell it) but would lack the strength. Both good with swords and work well in teams. It would be close but i would say Leonidas.

Leonidus probably. Most of the battles we saw in LoTR relied on Aragorn's pals (whole armies in some cases) and making good use of their strengths in battles, whilst Leonidus didn't have that luxury. Aragorn can heal quickly (he's a half elf or something), has a magical sword and can summon the Army of the Dead, but on a head to head basis, Leonidus, who as a Spartan fought off tigers (or bears, I can't remember which) in the wilderness as a kid would probably win.

Aragorn - he lasted over 9 hours whereas Leonidas could only manage about 2 :P