GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"Michael Schumacher - Greatest driver ever"

The "Freeola Customer Forum" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Sun 11/07/04 at 21:38
Regular
"Led Zeppelin"
Posts: 3,214
6 times world champion (1994, 1995, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003), 80th race wins........... can anyone stop him?
Wed 28/07/04 at 16:20
Regular
"bing bang bong"
Posts: 3,040
lalakersrule wrote:
> 'Much stiffer competition'?? Sorry but what career have you been
> watching?
>
> Damon Hill - average
> Mika Hakkinen - average
>
> And that's about it as far as proper rivals go, Raikkonen and Button
> are close but neither have proved yet to be top class drivers. Add
> the fact Schumacher has the Ferrari and there's no competition at
> all. The only guy that would give him a race and has shown him up to
> be very average on several occasions is Montoya, put him in a Ferrari
> and tell him he can race Schumie (well i doubt even if you told him
> not to it would make a difference) and then we'd see some proper
> action.

A lot of the drivers Fangio raced against were fatter than me, and I'm Tubby McLardBelly. Grand Prix racing has got a LOT more professional and a LOT more popular in the past twenty years - personal, organisational and technical standards have risen by orders of magnitude. I remember watching footage of the race at which James Hunt won his world championship in 1976 - drivers were coming into the pits unexpectedly and mechanics had to put out their fags and hurriedly get some tyres from the back of the pitlane! You can't tell me it wouldn't be vastly easier to excel in such an environment. If you were to put Schumacher or any of todays F1 drivers into such a sport, they would quickly rise to dominate it.

This is the same across many sports. Pele would be an average footballer in todays premiership. Jimmy Connors wouldn't stand a chance against todays tennis stars. They would have to raise their game like everyone else, and it's extremely doubtful that the top sportsmen from the 70's would be top sportsmen today - at the very least, they certainly wouldn't enjoy the margin over their peers today that they did in their time.


Also, fyi - average drivers don't win world titles. Hakkinen was brutally rapid his entire career, and Damon Hill nearly won a GP in an Arrows.
Wed 28/07/04 at 19:26
Regular
"Brooklyn boy"
Posts: 14,935
Miserableman wrote:

> This is the same across many sports. Pele would be an average
> footballer in todays premiership.

Speculation, no solid proof

Jimmy Connors wouldn't stand a
> chance against todays tennis stars.

Except Tim Henman :-D Anyway again speculation, no proof.

They would have to raise their
> game like everyone else, and it's extremely doubtful that the top
> sportsmen from the 70's would be top sportsmen today - at the very
> least, they certainly wouldn't enjoy the margin over their peers
> today that they did in their time.

Again Speculation, no proof.


> Also, fyi - average drivers don't win world titles. Hakkinen was
> brutally rapid his entire career, and Damon Hill nearly won a GP in
> an Arrows.

Ah finally something relating to my post, Ah yes Hakkinen was so rapid he didn't win a race until '97 when Villeneuve's car suddenly slowed down. Hill was in the fastest car when he won his title, average drivers can win titles if their car can make up for their lack of speed. Not so in other sports where athletes have to rely on themselves to do well, F1 is all about technology now, not driver skill, which only plays a small part sadly.
Wed 28/07/04 at 21:49
Regular
"bing bang bong"
Posts: 3,040
lalakersrule wrote:
> Speculation, no solid proof

Speculation is always going to figure in a debate about the best current driver versus drivers who died before he ever stepped into an F1 car.

> Ah finally something relating to my post, Ah yes Hakkinen was so
> rapid he didn't win a race until '97 when Villeneuve's car suddenly
> slowed down. Hill was in the fastest car when he won his title,
> average drivers can win titles if their car can make up for their
> lack of speed. Not so in other sports where athletes have to rely on
> themselves to do well, F1 is all about technology now, not driver
> skill, which only plays a small part sadly.

I don't recall any of Hakkinen's team-mates winning either, with the exception of Senna in Hakkinen's first year. Hill did win in the fastest car, but as Williams said at the time "he made the most of his machinery". He never qualified off the front row in '96, and if you look back at his race performances from that year they were not of an average driver in a good car.
Wed 28/07/04 at 22:07
Regular
"Too Orangy For Crow"
Posts: 15,844
I don't think Damon Hill was a merely average driver. When he drove for Williams in 1993, the car was superior but he did win 3 races and probably should have won 5 if it wasn't for engine glitches and tyres blowing up. Not bad for his first full season and beat Prost numerous times head to head.

1994 was a tough year. I wouldn't say the Williams was the dominant, greatest car on the track but Hill ran Schumacher right to the final race and it was only Schumacher's suspect tactics that denied Hill the title.

1995, the car was unreliable and probably would have pushed Schumacher again in what were almost identical cars as Benetton had Renault engines, the same as Williams.

1996, Hill finally got the title that I thought he deserved and it could have been 2. Villeneuve showed that year that he was good but Hill beat him that year.

1997, Hill got replaced by Frentzen and Frentzen did terrible. Hill went to Arrows, which was underpowered and pretty poor as it was in a transitional phase as Tom Walkinshaw had taken over the team. To drive that car to the front in Hungary was a masterful drive and it's the only drive I can remember in recent years when a team which has been near the bottom for the whole season, appear at the top. If it wasn't for a throttle problem, that race was his.

Then there were the Jordan years at the end of his career. He was ahead of Ralf Schumacher in Belguim when Jordan recorded their first win and 1-2 finish. He helped Jordan become a force as in later years, Frentzen won races at Jordan and was even a Championship contender with a few races left. His contribution was obviously invaluable as it was only money troubles at Jordan that have cost them recently. Otherwise they might still be there near the top.

I think Damon Hill was worthy of his title and probably should have had 2. Definitely not the greatest driver ever but definitely deserved the title he won, in my opinion of course. :)
Sat 31/07/04 at 21:30
Regular
"Led Zeppelin"
Posts: 3,214
Damon Hill won it before
Sat 31/07/04 at 23:05
Regular
"Led Zeppelin"
Posts: 3,214
Michael Schumacher playing football channel 5 thursday late night.

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

Great services and friendly support
I have been a subscriber to your service for more than 9 yrs. I have got at least 12 other people to sign up to Freeola. This is due to the great services offered and the responsive friendly support.
Just a quick note to say thanks for a very good service ... in fact excellent service..
I am very happy with your customer service and speed and quality of my broadband connection .. keep up the good work . and a good new year to all of you at freeola.
Matthew Bradley

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre
Feedback Close Feedback

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.