GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"People who say X-Box is rubbish and PS2 is better!!!"

The "Xbox Games" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Fri 12/10/01 at 17:13
Regular
Posts: 787
*How can this be true? It is four times more powerful, broadband internet connection, superior sound, much, much better graphics!! The games are also gonna be better!!!! Why???? Because the X-Box has over 150 developers making games for it! Also X-Box is getting most of the games Playstation 2 is getting, plus more!!! So how in any way can PS2 be better?*

**Just some of the amazing games to be released:**

AMPED FREESTYLE SNOWBOARDING
CHAMPIONSHIP MANAGER
DEAD OR ALIVE 3
DUKE NUKEM FOREVER
GRAND THEFT AUTO 3
HALO
HOUSE OF DEAD 3
JET SET RADIO FUTURE
CRAZY TAXI NEXT
MAX PAYNE
PROJECT GOTHAM RACING
METAL GEAR SOLID X
ODDWORLD: MUNCH'S ODDSSEY
SEGA GT 2000
SILENT HILL 2
SOUL CALIBUR 2
SSX TRICKY
TONY HAWKS PRO SKATER 3
UFC - TAPOUT
WWF RAW IS WAR
SHENMUE 3 (POSSIBLY)
NBA 2K2
RIDGE RACER

*PHEW!!! Now tell me X-Box is not good!!! These are just a few games being released, I haev just picked some of the best!*
Also, who is getting an X-Box? I hope to.
Thu 18/10/01 at 12:26
Posts: 0
X-box will be rubbish, primarily because it is made by Microsoft, who don't even haven the faintest idea about games consoles. Even their PC games are still not up to console standard, and they've been doing PC games for - about 12 years!.

PLUS, who wants a games console that crashes every five minutes, and then you probably find that every game you buy will require you to 'upgrade' the console in some form or another.

I just can't wait to see the X-Box being sold off at £50 after the first few months, because Microsoft have realised what a fool they were to create a device that flopped so spectacularly.

(Ideas for useless X-Boxes: Doorstop, Self-defence device, Seat)

PLUS, there'll be lawsuits from the hardware manufacturers, as they will claim Microsoft will be unfairly competeing again!

Roll on US DOJ!!
Thu 18/10/01 at 12:22
Regular
"l33t cs50r"
Posts: 2,956
WÚÛkiee M¯nßÜÄR wrote:
PS2 has Dolby Digital and DTS - the SAME as Xbox - though I'm
> not sure if Xbox supports DTS or not).

Bot support both formats due to the DVD playback capabilities, but Games developers have yet to work out a way of streaming 5.1 of a disc at the same time as the game so there won't be 5.1 games for a while yet!!

Also, 6.1 has arrived so will no doubt superseed 5.1 eventually in the next generation of consoles!!
Thu 18/10/01 at 12:19
Regular
"l33t cs50r"
Posts: 2,956
--Sorry made a
> mistake, X-ox has over 250 develpoers! Thanx for >reminding me.

And? Are they any good? What about Square, Enix, the big boys that tend to sell consoles (look at the N64 without thier suppoert!!).. They seem to be relying on SEGA and Cross Platform titles...

Have you seen Gotham running?... GT3 beater my a###, As for MGSX... GET WITH IT, IT AINT COMMING!!!

>They even have PS4 in planning, they are only interested in
> sequels so SONY mugs waste all their money on >continuously comming consoles!


New consoles are being developed before the previous one is even relased. It takes around 5 years to develop a new console and this development tends to start as soon as they release the previous one. The N64 was being developed before the SNES was launched and Mario64 took 6 years to make a fine tune.. The PS2 was around for years before the PS1, the innards were based on the engines used by Sony Pictures that created graphics like the ones seen in Godzilla!!

no doubt Nintendo are already working on the sequal to the GCN as for Microsoft, they just have to wait for the next "pantuim" chip and Riva card and hey presto... a new console...

And as for Sequals... Oddly enough, a majority of XBOX titles seem to be sequals or remakes...
Thu 18/10/01 at 12:08
Regular
"It goes so quickly"
Posts: 4,083
Well, I'll just wait to play the X-box before I say which is better.
Wed 17/10/01 at 19:29
Regular
Posts: 6,492
Sorry to annoy you Wookie, but..........

The PS2's doesn't contain a Dolby Digital 5.1 or DTS hardware decoder. Yes the PS2 can do these, but, as it has such an impact on the processor because it is the emotion engine which operates these, it will never be implemented during gameplay, according to Dolby anyway.

The Xbox on the other hand has a hardware Dolby Digital 5.1 and DTS controller, so the CPU is not encoding/decoding signals. This means that games for the Xbox will be able to produce these full digital surround sound environments during games. Games such as the Bouncer and Final Fantasy X have Dolby 5.1 FMV sequences, but do not have Dolby 5,1 in game.

As for sound quality, both the PS2 and Xbox are capable of producing DVD Audio quality, whatever the frequncy and bit rate of those are, but the Xbox hardware will be able to play more sounds simultaneously than the PS2. So in terms of quality, you wont be able to notice a difference really, because unless you have a massive sound system, the difference will not show.
Wed 17/10/01 at 19:23
Regular
"I dressed myself !!"
Posts: 494
Actually Wookie Monster! MIcrosft haev said that sound will be much better than PS2 adn Gc! Because you dont need to buy add ons or other things!! The sound has been inhanced with over 65 channels!! Trust me X-Box sound will be much clearer more precise adn more sounds will be released than anything PS2 could do!
Sat 13/10/01 at 18:01
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
Console_kid wrote:
> Not only does PS2 support Dolby Digital 5.1 and Digital
> Theatre Surround, but the human ear can only distinguish so many sounds at once
> - so you wouldn't notice much difference anyway!

**there will be more games.
> It is digital Dolby surround sound, much superior to PS2. the surround and digital
> will be noticable.

Did you not read my post? PS2 has Dolby Digital and DTS - the SAME as Xbox - though I'm not sure if Xbox supports DTS or not).

There can be no difference, and it can't be more noticeable on one machine than the other, because it is a STANDARD.

For both machines, you will need to buy a Dolby Digital decoder to hear any surround sound whatsoever.
Sat 13/10/01 at 12:27
Regular
"I dressed myself !!"
Posts: 494
Wookies Honour said:
>>Console_kid wrote:
> Sorry made a mistake, X-ox has over 250 develpoers!

Ah, outdone on the numbers, so the numbers change for a classic case of "mine's bigger than yours".

** That was actually a genuine mistake. X-Box does haev over 250 develpoers!

What you need to remember is that few of the developers are exclusive to any platform, and the same goes for the software they are producing. With the exception of a handful of titles, most games will be available on at least two of the three platforms (PS2, Gamecube and Xbox).

**thats true but that does not stop Microsoft from buying rigths to games!!! Nintendo have bought all rights to Resident Evil so no other console can haev Resi Evil games!

> I dont see why you are comparing it with your PC? X-Box is not a PC

It's an Intel Pentium 3 processor with a GeForce 3 graphics card; it's as close to a PC as you're going to get in a console.

**Dreamcast worked on Windows CE! That did not make it a PC!


> and its games WONT be comming to PC so who really cares if your PC is more powerful!

No, but a lot of its games will be coming FROM the PC.

**thats not true! What about dead or alive 3, SSx Tricky, Crazy Taxi Next, Jet Set Radio Future.. loads! Just check out my post on X-Boxs games!

> like you said the main thing is that it appeals to different gamers.

Indeed - so what's your problem?

**i dont have a problem. Do you?

> But, Sony Blatenely ripps off its customers!!

And Microsoft don't? How many versions of windows? How many bugfixes? And who's been in court for unfair practices?

**LOL!! WINDOWS NEEDS TO BE UPDATED!!!!! ITS NOT A FUN GAME OF MAKING CONSOLES, FOR BUSINESS ADN COMPANIES TO RUN PROPERLY BETTER TECHNOLOGY AND WINDOWS UPDATES ARE NEEDED! LOL, I CANT BELIEVE YOU EVEN MADE THIS POINT, IT IS SOOO VITAL THAT COMPANIES LIKE MICROSOFT UPDATE SOFTWARE!


> They even have PS4 in planning, they are only interested in
> sequels so SONY mugs waste all their money on continuously comming consoles!

No, they have PS3 in planning. And Microsoft have their next machine in planning also - called (for now) the HomeStation.

**actually i read they already have PS4 in planning!


> oh, and guess what??? X-Box only has more games comming out, better graphics, better sound,
> internet!

More games is questionable, better graphics is obvious because the machine has two years of further graphics development to call on, and better sound is also questionable. Not only does PS2 support Dolby Digital 5.1 and Digital Theatre Surround, but the human ear can only distinguish so many sounds at once - so you wouldn't notice much difference anyway!

**there will be more games. As you said graphics will be much better, and there is much better sound. It is digital Dolby surround sound, much superior to PS2. the surround and digital will be noticable. The sound chip has been inhanced

> And you dont have to hadn over more money to Microsoft for extras
> like Sony are doing!

Erm... check the Xbox site. There are plenty of extras you have to buy. The Xbox doesn't even play DVD's without the additional purchase of an additional DVD Playback Kit!

**yeah but DVD, has nothignt o do with consoles gaming! its pointless having DVD! most DVD's can be played on Pc's now! Most people have a DVD player.

> Payign extra for online capabilities, well that comes with
> an X-Box!

I'd rather have the DVD playback straight off than the online capability, but that's my personal preference.

**as you said its down to opinion. I WOULD MUCH PREFER TO BE ABLE TO PLAY ONLINE SHOOT EM UPS, WITH 18 ONLINE PLAYERS IN ONE GAME!!! THAN WATCHING A DVD!

> You dont haev to buy memory cards like Sony cos memory is stored on
> X-Box! So thats Sony tucking you up again!

Again, check the Xbox web site. They list both official and unofficial 8Mb memory cards; so they're obviously necessary.

**you can if you want! but that is only if you wanna go around a friends house and upload that data! with PS2 you HAVE TO HAVE A MEM CARD, with X-Box it is optional!


> Oh, X-Box has 4 controller ports! and how many does Sony have???

Well, yippee doo! Buy two multitaps - ONLY if you want them - and have EIGHT players!

**EXACTLY! another example of Sony tucking up its customers!


> customers! also with X-Box you dotn haev to keep updating with newer versions of the console being released
> every month..... but you can update it!!!!!!!

The Xbox case design has no visible screws for the user to open the case. Opening the unit invalidates the warranty, and can only be done by service personnel. How are you going to update that, then?

**i dont actually work for Microsoft, so i dont know, but that is what X-Box central and Bill Gates said!!!
Sat 13/10/01 at 00:19
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
Console_kid wrote:
> Sorry made a mistake, X-ox has over 250 develpoers!

Ah, outdone on the numbers, so the numbers change for a classic case of "mine's bigger than yours".

What you need to remember is that few of the developers are exclusive to any platform, and the same goes for the software they are producing. With the exception of a handful of titles, most games will be available on at least two of the three platforms (PS2, Gamecube and Xbox).


> I dont see why you are comparing it with your PC? X-Box is not a PC

It's an Intel Pentium 3 processor with a GeForce 3 graphics card; it's as close to a PC as you're going to get in a console.


> and its games WONT be comming to PC so who really cares if your PC is more powerful!

No, but a lot of its games will be coming FROM the PC.


> like you said the main thing is that it appeals to different gamers.

Indeed - so what's your problem?


> But, Sony Blatenely ripps off its customers!!

And Microsoft don't? How many versions of windows? How many bugfixes? And who's been in court for unfair practices?


> They even have PS4 in planning, they are only interested in
> sequels so SONY mugs waste all their money on continuously comming consoles!

No, they have PS3 in planning. And Microsoft have their next machine in planning also - called (for now) the HomeStation.


> oh, and guess what??? X-Box only has more games comming out, better graphics, better sound,
> internet!

More games is questionable, better graphics is obvious because the machine has two years of further graphics development to call on, and better sound is also questionable. Not only does PS2 support Dolby Digital 5.1 and Digital Theatre Surround, but the human ear can only distinguish so many sounds at once - so you wouldn't notice much difference anyway!

> And you dont have to hadn over more money to Microsoft for extras
> like Sony are doing!

Erm... check the Xbox site. There are plenty of extras you have to buy. The Xbox doesn't even play DVD's without the additional purchase of an additional DVD Playback Kit!


> Payign extra for online capabilities, well that comes with
> an X-Box!

I'd rather have the DVD playback straight off than the online capability, but that's my personal preference.


> You dont haev to buy memory cards like Sony cos memory is stored on
> X-Box! So thats Sony tucking you up again!

Again, check the Xbox web site. They list both official and unofficial 8Mb memory cards; so they're obviously necessary.


> Oh, X-Box has 4 controller ports! and how many does Sony have???

Well, yippee doo! Buy two multitaps - ONLY if you want them - and have EIGHT players!


> customers! also with X-Box you dotn haev to keep updating with newer versions of the console being released
> every month..... but you can update it!!!!!!!

The Xbox case design has no visible screws for the user to open the case. Opening the unit invalidates the warranty, and can only be done by service personnel. How are you going to update that, then?
Fri 12/10/01 at 19:33
Regular
"Back For Good"
Posts: 3,673
Don't make a habit of this!!!

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

Thank you very much for your help!
Top service for free - excellent - thank you very much for your help.
Just a quick note to say thanks for a very good service ... in fact excellent service..
I am very happy with your customer service and speed and quality of my broadband connection .. keep up the good work . and a good new year to all of you at freeola.
Matthew Bradley

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre
Feedback Close Feedback

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.