Viewing Thread:
"Shigeru Miyamoto Vs. Hideo Kojima!"

Mario Vs. Snake Solid? - Not quite, these, as you all probably know, are the men behind the two gaming icons. Shigsy has a litle more creativity, but there's no doubting that Hideo is one hell of a games maker!

MGS2 is probably the most sound game around. I know all of you will have your preferances, but through the critics eye, MGS2 is near-prefect...

But then again, would there be room for Snake Solid if Mario hadn't opened up the gaming industry?! I don't think so!

In my book, Shigsy wins, not just because of his 'wacky' games, although they're a deciding factor, but more because of what he's done for the industry. Mario Bros. broke ground... it has done everytime an installment of the series was released... and then running around in full 3D in Super Mario 64... Gaming heaven!

I don't really think Hideo has done half as much for the industry... My views may be one-sided, but I don't see how...

Based on my knowledge... which isn't loads but a lot... Shigsy is overall a better contributor to the industry...

Shigsy 1 - 0 Hideo

Who'll score next?

You decide.


Game

Shigsy, Kojima
Shigsy, Kojima
Shigsy, Kojima
Shigsy, Kojima

NAKA: "Is there a third option?"

Sonic ;)

LOL

I am the Tarrant wrote:
> This is a terrible argument. I believe it was a 'state your opinion'
> type question anyway!
Lets not resort to name calling!

Ok then... Sorry Ant.

P.S Shigsy Wins!

This is a terrible argument. I believe it was a 'state your opinion' type question anyway!
Lets not resort to name calling!

er-no wrote:
> Ant wrote:

Hideo
> Kojima wins!

Thats not what the award
> said!

>Shigsy Wins!

Ah, but who cares about material awards?? It's what's in people's hearts that counts.

So.....KOJIMA WINS!

I think that Archer Mcclain is better than them both put together. Mario? Pah! Metal Gear? Pah!

Give me IK+ any day!


(Anyone else remember IK+? It was mint!)

Ant wrote:

Hideo
> Kojima wins!

Thats not what the award said!

Shigsy Wins!

er-no wrote:
> Shiguru Miyamoto won the award for the best man in the world of
> video gaming for the millennium.

>Shigeru Miyamoto wins!

Yes, but Kojima has really only just entered the world of gaming.

Shigsy's games are...well in my opinion...boring. Mario has got boring.

Kojima is combining superb plots and superb gameplay, to make awesome games-and Kojima is doing lots of new things as well.

Hideo Kojima wins!

Shiguru Miyamoto won the award for the best man in the world of video gaming for the millennium.

Shigeru Miyamoto wins!

Okay, so Shigsy has had more input into the gaming world-as he helps with the consoles etc.

But the question really is: Who makes the best games?

And for me, that's Hideo Kojima.