Viewing Thread:
"How much is your team worth?"

List your starting line up and how much you think they are worth.

Spurs

Keller - £2.5 mil
Carr - £10 mil (I believe Newcastle put a bid of this in for him)
Gardner - £7 mil (according to Stuart, I agree :-D)
King - £6 mil
Tarrico - Free (maybe half a mil if they're stupid!)

Both King and Gardner will increase, as they are both young and both have possibilities of England careers ahead of them.

Davies - £15-17 mil (When on form, he's amazing, when he's injured or off form (most of the time) well....ahem)
Brown - £3 mil
Redknapp - Free

Kanoute - £11 mil (at least)
Defoe - £11 mil (as above, at least)
Keane - £15 mil

Yeh, your turn

Based on this seasons performance United wouldn't be worth more than a couple of quid and a couple of pongs. There's only been a couple of performances where the real United have shown up and played football like we all know they can. The very fact that we lost against Wolves this season is reason enough to flog the lot of them and rebuild.

The only highlight has been young twinkletoes Ronaldo, that kid is going to be one of the best wingers in the future.

Wakka wrote:
> Before yesterday's beating by Portsmouth, Man U had never lost with
> Carrrol in goal. That is why he was in.

You just contradicted yourself and handed Game,set and match to Lil bro.

Man Utd haven't lost with Carroll, yet they have with Howard.

That would therefore suggest that perhaps Carroll is a better keeper....

Lil Bro wrote:
> Ashman wrote:
> Lil Bro wrote:
> Carr - £10 mil (I believe Newcastle put a bid of this in for
> him)

Chelsea bid £84.1 million for Raul at some point. That doesn't mean he's worth is....

> You'd be lucky...
>
> Easily. Talking crap mate :-D

Oh the hypocrisy.

You just said Carr was worth 10 mil. And Davies was worth 17 mil. Ha.

I'd say carr = 6mil

Davies = 8 mil

Keane = 11 mil

Ashman wrote:
> I've never known a team buy a goalkeeper for £19million, he is
> class, but not even close to being worth that much.

Juve bought Buffon for £28 million, I think.

UNITEDLEGENDS159 wrote:
> Lil Bro wrote:
> No, but your name seems to suggest that you think your Man Utd
> opinions are correct, and you are unwilling to listen to criticism
> about your team.
>
> I can take criticism, but when you say a player is past it when he is
> 28, and saying that he is useless because he has red hair. It's just
> not a proper argument

I agree. That is like me saying Simon Davies is past it, he has curly hair. It doesn't matter about their colour of hair.

Lil Bro wrote:
> Wakka wrote:
> Paul Scholes - Anything over 30 million (The best Man U player and I
> think one of the best midfielders in the World)
>
> Hmmmmm...i'd say £25million but your not wrong when you say
> he's the best Man United player.
>
> AHEM. Ruud van Nistelrooy?
>
> I rate Scholes higher than Ruud.
>
> Then you are a fool. Ruud is bloody class, and even I, as a Spurs fan
> admit that he is incredible. Second best striker in the P'ship after
> Henry, and come on, being second to Henry isn't exactly a bad thing
> now is it?

I agree that Ruud is brilliant and second best to Henry. But I Rate Scholes higher. Okay!

Lil Bro wrote:
> Wakka wrote:
> Manchester United -
>
> Tim Howard - 19 million (I think he is the best goalie in the
> Premiership at the moment.)
>
> SO that would make Carroll worth more than him? Seeing as Carroll is
> currently your number one goalie, explain this to me...
>
> Tim Howard is the best goalie in the Premiership yet Carroll starts
> ahead of him, and Fergie admits Carroll is currently the better
> goalie....
>
> Back to school for you methinks...

Before yesterday's beating by Portsmouth, Man U had never lost with Carrrol in goal. That is why he was in.

Ashman wrote:
> Lil Bro wrote:
> Carr - £10 mil (I believe Newcastle put a bid of this in for
> him)
>
> You'd be lucky...

Easily. Talking crap mate :-D

>
> Davies - £15-17 mil (When on form, he's amazing, when he's
> injured or off form (most of the time) well....ahem)
>
> Davies is good, im not argueing that, but when you consider Duff went
> for £17mil, I can't see you getting more than £12mil for
> Davies.

Ok, maybe a slight over-exagerration but I remember us turning down a bid of that from Newcastle a year or so ago so he must be worth something around that mark. I still rate him very highly he's just been bloody unlucky with injuries. Still, he's only 24.

>
> Keane - £15 mil
>
> As good as Robbie is, again, you'd have to be lucky.

Worth every penny of it, consistantly brilliant for us and Ireland.

Lil Bro wrote:
> Carr - £10 mil (I believe Newcastle put a bid of this in for
> him)

You'd be lucky...

> Davies - £15-17 mil (When on form, he's amazing, when he's
> injured or off form (most of the time) well....ahem)

Davies is good, im not argueing that, but when you consider Duff went for £17mil, I can't see you getting more than £12mil for Davies.

> Keane - £15 mil

As good as Robbie is, again, you'd have to be lucky.

Giggs best winger?!