The "General Games Chat" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.
Having a large percentage go wrong would be silly and probably criminal in some way.
> That said: you're in the minority as the PS2's faults are well
> documented with accusations of designed obsolescence etc.
True.
But then as I say, my original launch-model PS2 is still going strong.
I don't doubt that many have had problems, but the claims of 'designed obsolescence' must be rubbish... otherwise my machine wouldn't still be working, would it?
Anyway, now I really am off to bed. :-)
I've got to admit that if that'd happened to me I'd be thinking twice before getting a 360. That said: you're in the minority as the PS2's faults are well documented with accusations of designed obsolescence etc.
> Again thats your own opinion to be fair
Did I claim it to be anything else?
> personally i would say the 360 is more capable then the PS3 no matter
> what the stats say.
Interesting. For Xbox v PS2, stats were all Xbox fans ever through out. Now that they favour the competition, they don't matter.
> Heh, "we're good because we say so".
Yes, but they've proven it with Killzone. A real achievement, given the age of the hardware.
> And? Nobody's disputing whether these people are capable of making
> good games: it the methods they use when they've got nothing to show
> that aren't good.
But even if you discount the 'real' FMV, the Unreal demo is 'real' and looks as good as FMV.
> But there's no proof, just hype.
See above.
Graphically, 360 and PS3 are going to be almost identical, except that PS3 will output at a higher resolution if you have a suitable TV. Unless you have or can afford a HDTV, you won't get the best out of it graphically anyway.
The difference will come from elsewhere. With more storage space and almost twice the floating point processing power, PS3 should (not will) allow for more involving environments.
Anyway, is there any point arguing about it? You'll choose yours, I'll choose mine, and nothing either of us says will change the mind of the other.
Go and order your PS2 and controller adapter! :-)
> But an accurate representation of what they can achieve, according to
> the developer.
Heh, "we're good because we say so".
> The first footage of GT3 was only FMV, and everyone said "you
> won't get graphics like that on PS2". But they did. And GT4 is
> better still.
And? Nobody's disputing whether these people are capable of making good games: it the methods they use when they've got nothing to show that aren't good.
>
> What I've seen of the 360 is good. Given that PS3 is more powerful
> still, there's every likelyhood that Killzone will look at least as
> good as the FMV.
>
But there's no proof, just hype.
> Anyway, as I said elsewhere, the Unreal Engine 3 demo was a
> real demo, and looks at least as good as anything on 360.
But as we've said the games are running on less powerful setups than the final 360 titles will be run on - so those 360 titles will probably look better.
> Sony fan boy and his Killzone!
Yes, I am a Sony fan, and I've never made any secret of it.
> How much of a let down was the 1st?
Not at all. I loved it. Actually stopped playing Halo 2 until I'd finished Killzone. In fact, while it's far better than the first, I haven't touched Halo 2 since February.
I've said for a long time that, for me, the Xbox was a let-down.
They dropped the price by £100 just 4 weeks after launch, which peed me off intensely; my hard drive failed and needed replacing, losing my saves; and then I discovered that the whole damn thing was a fire hazard because someone at Microsoft can't wire a plug correctly!
And all the while my original launch model PS2 still functions perfectly.
Even if I hadn't preferred Sony beforehand, I certainly do now!
Is it any wonder that I'm looking forward to the PS3 more than the 360?
Apparently Killzone's not good and I know Mace Griffin wasn't a patch on Halo. Then there was all the "This'll be the playstation's Goldeneye" crap that we got ages ago and it all ends up being a bunch of balls.
People are waking up, it's nice to see a fair amount of honesty being used this time rather than the age old hype machine that everyone with half a brain is now very aware of.