The "Freeola Customer Forum" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.
Don't say stupid things like "it's brilliant" give me true reasons of why you think it's popular.
But I feel a band screaming down a mic can convey
> more emotion than anyone with their perfectly tuned voice singing
> about...
Exactly. Music is always better when it makes you feel.
That's what is so terrible about radio-friendly-unit-shifting music. It doesn't make you feel. It can't - be definition, a radio-friendly song cannot make anyone feel, because then it wouldn't be radio friendly. Imagine what would happen if Chris Moyles tried to play decent, mood changing music - it would be an emotional disaster. If you went from some angry Tool stuff to Counting Crows to Otis Redding, it just wouldn't work.
Oh, and I think a lot of music is about memory. Heartbreaker always reminds me of a party I went to once. Better Than Ezras - Closer reminds me of my holiday in France.
Anyway, heavy bands (most of them anyway) do not just mash a guitar or hit the drums as fast as possible, it is just a stereotype by people who don't like alternative rock music to try and make out like you need no skill to play heavy music...
> Thanks for your replys, but one more
> If normal music is soothing and uplifting then what would you think
> songs that are done by people who can't even speak more than one word
> at a time, like Marylin Manson, SlipNot, Sum41 and all those other
> Modern rock groups, why are they so popular since they are not
> soothing and uplifting?
Lol, so I assume you can speak more than one word at a time...? If anyone could speak more than one word at a time they'd probably confuse everyone as no-one would be able to differentiate between the different words they were saying... or something... anyway, enough picking at your grammer (or lack thereof :D) I'll make the assumption that you don't just mean the popular 'heavy' bands out there, but you mean alternative rock music in general.
Much of it is angst driven. It appeals to teenagers who are sick of radio friendly music and want something different, maybe rebellious. People enjoy it because of many reasons. While a lot of music you can just put on in the background, something heavy can grab you by the balls and not let go. It can force you to focus on it. And music isn't there to sooth you. It is there (or at least should be) to convey a message and/or an emotion. Shame so much of the stuff we're bombarded with does neither. But I feel a band screaming down a mic can convey more emotion than anyone with their perfectly tuned voice singing about... God knows... listen to some S club 7 songs and you try to figure out what they're supposed to be singing about... Thing about rock music. It can be raw and just simply an adrenaline rush, but it often does tries to convey something. To a certain extent it doesn't even matter whether it's trying to convey hate, love, despair, hope, disgust, politics, or anything, because it is still trying to convey some kind of emotion, which I feel just isn't done enough in music. Too much is just throwaway music.
Hope my essay cleared some points up :D
> Thanks for your replys, but one more
> If normal music is soothing and uplifting then what would you think
> songs that are done by people who can't even speak more than one word
> at a time, like Marylin Manson, SlipNot, Sum41 and all those other
> Modern rock groups, why are they so popular since they are not
> soothing and uplifting?
Speak for yourself. Fear Factory always send me right off to sleep. I find Heavy Metal helps me rid myself of Angst. Its the only music I can get completely lost in. Its a matter of taste. I think that R&B is tuneless rubish. but others may beg to differ
Doesn't have to be your cup of tea, but someone striving to articulate a feeling within.