GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"Broadband Access"

The "General Games Chat" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Sun 07/04/02 at 20:36
Regular
Posts: 787
With the PS2 and XBox offering us online gameplay soon, it seems appropriate to look into the niche of broadband access. The XBox simply will not allow modem access, and using a modem to dial in to play PS2 games will prove tedious and slow. Thus broadband access will be an absolute must for customers wishing to play online.

To my knowledge, only two parent companies offer broadband access in the United Kingdom. These are BT and NTL/Telewest. But which one will offer the best connection, and how do they compare in value?

As an NTL customer, which is offers the same service as telewest, I know a fair bit about the service they offer. NTL offers two broadband packages, a high speed 512kpbs connection, and a slower connection at 128kbps. For comparison, the fastest modems will connect you to the internet at roughly 56kpbs. NTL's slower connection will set you back £15 per month, while the faster connection will cost £25 per month. Both prices include rental of a Terayon TeraJet cable modem. However, you can save a bit on the line rental by buying the modem, which costs roughly £100. There is also a one-off connection charge of £25, which covers installation. The line rental is based on a 12 month contract, but the good news is that you can switch between the fast and slow connection at will simply by calling NTL. This means if you are not happy with £25 per month, you can give them a call and knock it back to £15 per month. It all really depends on how much you want from the internet. However, it must be stressed that online play will probably demand a fast 512kbps connection for smooth play.

NTL and Telewest are also only available in cable enabled areas. I am lucky to be living in a region with high NTL coverage, but my parents live where NTL is not available. It is possible however to do a quick postcode check on the internet to find out if you are eligible. This is based at www.ntl.com. So, the price seems reasonable, but is this too good to be true?

During my time with NTL's broadband access I can only really report good news. The modem has never once lost the network, and download speeds are constantly peaking at 60kbps on my quick connection. This will be good news for gamers, as you will never really have to worry about the speed of your cable modem. The internet service is top notch, but it is a pity the customer service isn't quite up to the standard.

This is a sore point for me. When NTL came to fit my broadband access, which occured after only a week of ordering the service, I was a little disappointed. The engineer was moody, and didn't leave me with any instructions, as he supposedly should have. I called the number I had recieved for tech support, and decided to sort the problem out. However, I reached the tyneside office after 1 hour of queing, and was given a midlands number. At this point, I was getting frustrated, and another 1.5 hours on the phone in a queue didn't help my cause.

Eventually, after wading through automated answerphones galore, I spoke to a broadband representative. He instructed me to access a registration page, and it went smoothly from there on. However, if you encounter any problems from then on, be prepared to wait for any help. Another point may be the status of NTL/Telewest as a company. Are they worth investing in for the future? Well with a £50 million debt it hardly seems promising, and if you opt for NTL/Telewest, look out for dodgy bills. Such a fate has happened to me on more than one occasion, and yes, you have to queue to complain.

However, bad points aside, the connection is reportedly the best of the bunch. However, the service, future, and availability leave a little to be desired.

Now what about British Telecom. A reputable company offering broadband access to any home in the UK. The future looks bright, as BT are a well established company, and the service is top notch. So what about the connection? Well BT connects using ADSL, a phone-line type connection, compared to NTL's fibre-optic cable link. It will connect you at roughly 500kbps, and is report to be slightly slower than the NTL cable link. But how does it compare in price?

To be honest, BT are asking a fairly steep price for the service. They set out a £29.99 per month line rental, for which you could get a slightly quicker cable link for £5 less per month. However, if this is an investment in the future, it could well be worth paying the extra simply for the service and outlook. BT also charge £85 one off for an ADSL modem, which is slightly expensive considering you can get one included in your £25 per month from NTL. BT are currently purporting 'free activation' as part of a limited offer. I will equate this to the £25 one off charged by NTL. However, this offer is of a finite lifetime, and when the offer ends, they will charge £65 for the privilege.

So, for a high speed broadband package in cable enabled areas you will be looking at:

NTL

Line Rental = £25 per month = £300 per year
Installation = £25
Total for one year = £325

BT

Line Rental = £30 per month = £360 per year
Activation = £65
ADSL modem = £85
Total for one year = £510

NTL clearly offer the best value, and also the best connection to match. So, looking at the figures, NTL is the best bet. However, if you catch BT while the offer is on, the price will drop to £445 per year, but still £120 more than NTL ask.

For the future, BT however offer the brightest outlook, in terms of investment, future, and service. I expect BT will be able to buffer a price drop in the future without losing profit, which is a bonus. It is arguable whether NTL will be able to afford to reduce prices with the companies current status, but the future is left to be determined. What can be said with some degree of confidence is that prices will drop rapidly. Especially with the advent of online gaming to the masses, the telecommunication companies will no doubt be in tough competition with each other in terms of value and speed.

So to sum up, I would put my money with NTL. If all goes pear shaped, a contractual clause will allow you to nullify the contract in the event of any price changes. But be warned, BT may offer a significantly better value package when XBox Live hits the internet, and it may be better to put your money on a safer horse. At the end of the day, if you are serious about online gaming and the future, you need to start considering your options for broadband access. With titles such as FFXI waiting around the corner, would we really want to miss out?

I hope this comparison offers assistance to those of you venturing into the realms of broadband access, and I hope you can make a wise and informed decision on what suits you. Thanks for reading!
Sun 07/04/02 at 21:36
Posts: 0
512kbps down 212kbps up, heh got them the wrong way round.
Sun 07/04/02 at 21:35
Posts: 0
Soon i will be getting ADSL from Demon the bog standard package 512kbps up 212kbps down, nicely priced at £28.99 per month have to buy the DSL modem yourself though. Although for any rich gits thinking of getting broadband i would recommend SDSL very nice that :)
Sun 07/04/02 at 21:31
Posts: 0
BT are in worse debt that telewest and NTL and the Telewest customer services are great and Good service of installation
Sun 07/04/02 at 21:12
Regular
"Chavez, just hush.."
Posts: 11,080
Im pretty sure though that to qualify for NTL broadband you have got to buy the full NTL package. Im looking now on the website....................

O.K I got it, look down

New Customers
- Pay a monthly subscription of £52.98* which includes subscription to our entry-level digital cable television service and the rental of a telephone line + subscription to our Hi-Speed broadband Internet service**.

Thats a lot of money, and for a house already with Sky Digital and a very good BT phone package, its jsut pointless. The £30 that BT charge will be better value for me. From what I've seen, its what phone company that you are with that makes the difference. Im staying with BT and my dial up modem, its all I really need at the moment.
Sun 07/04/02 at 20:36
Posts: 0
With the PS2 and XBox offering us online gameplay soon, it seems appropriate to look into the niche of broadband access. The XBox simply will not allow modem access, and using a modem to dial in to play PS2 games will prove tedious and slow. Thus broadband access will be an absolute must for customers wishing to play online.

To my knowledge, only two parent companies offer broadband access in the United Kingdom. These are BT and NTL/Telewest. But which one will offer the best connection, and how do they compare in value?

As an NTL customer, which is offers the same service as telewest, I know a fair bit about the service they offer. NTL offers two broadband packages, a high speed 512kpbs connection, and a slower connection at 128kbps. For comparison, the fastest modems will connect you to the internet at roughly 56kpbs. NTL's slower connection will set you back £15 per month, while the faster connection will cost £25 per month. Both prices include rental of a Terayon TeraJet cable modem. However, you can save a bit on the line rental by buying the modem, which costs roughly £100. There is also a one-off connection charge of £25, which covers installation. The line rental is based on a 12 month contract, but the good news is that you can switch between the fast and slow connection at will simply by calling NTL. This means if you are not happy with £25 per month, you can give them a call and knock it back to £15 per month. It all really depends on how much you want from the internet. However, it must be stressed that online play will probably demand a fast 512kbps connection for smooth play.

NTL and Telewest are also only available in cable enabled areas. I am lucky to be living in a region with high NTL coverage, but my parents live where NTL is not available. It is possible however to do a quick postcode check on the internet to find out if you are eligible. This is based at www.ntl.com. So, the price seems reasonable, but is this too good to be true?

During my time with NTL's broadband access I can only really report good news. The modem has never once lost the network, and download speeds are constantly peaking at 60kbps on my quick connection. This will be good news for gamers, as you will never really have to worry about the speed of your cable modem. The internet service is top notch, but it is a pity the customer service isn't quite up to the standard.

This is a sore point for me. When NTL came to fit my broadband access, which occured after only a week of ordering the service, I was a little disappointed. The engineer was moody, and didn't leave me with any instructions, as he supposedly should have. I called the number I had recieved for tech support, and decided to sort the problem out. However, I reached the tyneside office after 1 hour of queing, and was given a midlands number. At this point, I was getting frustrated, and another 1.5 hours on the phone in a queue didn't help my cause.

Eventually, after wading through automated answerphones galore, I spoke to a broadband representative. He instructed me to access a registration page, and it went smoothly from there on. However, if you encounter any problems from then on, be prepared to wait for any help. Another point may be the status of NTL/Telewest as a company. Are they worth investing in for the future? Well with a £50 million debt it hardly seems promising, and if you opt for NTL/Telewest, look out for dodgy bills. Such a fate has happened to me on more than one occasion, and yes, you have to queue to complain.

However, bad points aside, the connection is reportedly the best of the bunch. However, the service, future, and availability leave a little to be desired.

Now what about British Telecom. A reputable company offering broadband access to any home in the UK. The future looks bright, as BT are a well established company, and the service is top notch. So what about the connection? Well BT connects using ADSL, a phone-line type connection, compared to NTL's fibre-optic cable link. It will connect you at roughly 500kbps, and is report to be slightly slower than the NTL cable link. But how does it compare in price?

To be honest, BT are asking a fairly steep price for the service. They set out a £29.99 per month line rental, for which you could get a slightly quicker cable link for £5 less per month. However, if this is an investment in the future, it could well be worth paying the extra simply for the service and outlook. BT also charge £85 one off for an ADSL modem, which is slightly expensive considering you can get one included in your £25 per month from NTL. BT are currently purporting 'free activation' as part of a limited offer. I will equate this to the £25 one off charged by NTL. However, this offer is of a finite lifetime, and when the offer ends, they will charge £65 for the privilege.

So, for a high speed broadband package in cable enabled areas you will be looking at:

NTL

Line Rental = £25 per month = £300 per year
Installation = £25
Total for one year = £325

BT

Line Rental = £30 per month = £360 per year
Activation = £65
ADSL modem = £85
Total for one year = £510

NTL clearly offer the best value, and also the best connection to match. So, looking at the figures, NTL is the best bet. However, if you catch BT while the offer is on, the price will drop to £445 per year, but still £120 more than NTL ask.

For the future, BT however offer the brightest outlook, in terms of investment, future, and service. I expect BT will be able to buffer a price drop in the future without losing profit, which is a bonus. It is arguable whether NTL will be able to afford to reduce prices with the companies current status, but the future is left to be determined. What can be said with some degree of confidence is that prices will drop rapidly. Especially with the advent of online gaming to the masses, the telecommunication companies will no doubt be in tough competition with each other in terms of value and speed.

So to sum up, I would put my money with NTL. If all goes pear shaped, a contractual clause will allow you to nullify the contract in the event of any price changes. But be warned, BT may offer a significantly better value package when XBox Live hits the internet, and it may be better to put your money on a safer horse. At the end of the day, if you are serious about online gaming and the future, you need to start considering your options for broadband access. With titles such as FFXI waiting around the corner, would we really want to miss out?

I hope this comparison offers assistance to those of you venturing into the realms of broadband access, and I hope you can make a wise and informed decision on what suits you. Thanks for reading!

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

The coolest ISP ever!
In my opinion, the ISP is the best I have ever used. They guarantee 'first time connection - everytime', which they have never let me down on.
My website looks tremendous!
Fantastic site, easy to follow, simple guides... impressed with whole package. My website looks tremendous. You don't need to be a rocket scientist to set this up, Freeola helps you step-by-step.
Susan

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.