GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"Shameful."

The "Freeola Customer Forum" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Thu 14/02/02 at 12:05
Regular
Posts: 787
From the BBC website and other news sources:

"Hollywood couple Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon are to make a film about the 11 September attacks in New York, focusing on the bravery of a British security officer.
Robbins and Sarandon are to base their film on the bravery of Rick Rescorla, a Cornwall-born war hero, who died in the attacks saving thousands of people.

The film is based on an article by James Stewart in the New Yorker magazine, All The Heroes Are Dead, and is one of three productions about the attacks on the Twin Towers currently in planning

The film will concentrate on the love story between the couple, described as "two fractured people who found each other late in life and enjoyed a storybook romance".
The World Trade Center disaster will provide a cruel finale to the film."

----

A love story using the WTC as a backdrop.
They didnt even wait a year.
Thu 14/02/02 at 17:21
Regular
"That's right!"
Posts: 10,645
WòókieeMøn§†€® wrote:

I still remember sitting
> at home watching the news and bursting into tears at the film of people throwing
> themselves from the buildings. How do the minds work to make a love story out
> of something like that?

-------------

They're not, they're making a love story to give the story some more volume (yes, I know that's crazy) so they don't get totally slated for the film being "hollow"

Man, that's just stupid!

Adding the love story and making it the main point is what will get them slated


Fair enough if the love story is used to create emotion, as it's a lot easier to do that if we can relate to the characters, instead of just having clip after clip after clip of random people dying


But if the love story IS the main point, and the WTC attack is just a backdrop, they should be given a slap on the wrist
Thu 14/02/02 at 17:19
Regular
"Wasting away"
Posts: 2,230
It does seem sudden and because of what happened to you, I can see how you're so angry about it all. The same could be said though about Black Hawk Down, due to it's early release. War films could be too much for some people to sit through and Schindler's List is a prime example of this. But, Schindler's List did not have a love story, and just for the hell of it mention the fact that 11,000,000 Jewish people were being terminated and he got involved for fun.

It is a sad thing to happen and I find it hard to believe they could base an actual film around it. Documentaries, fine. Film, no way. Not only was it the news of the decade, not only was it the most tragic thing to happen in my life, but, it only happened a matter of months ago.
Thu 14/02/02 at 17:11
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
Goatboy wrote:
> Instead, it's a couple of beautiful people pretending they know
> what that feels like.


This is the aspect I object to.

If the film was to be a documentary feature detailing the actual facts of the event, I would find it much more acceptable. Though I still think it is too soon - maybe an absolute minimum of five years after the event.

I still remember sitting at home watching the news and bursting into tears at the film of people throwing themselves from the buildings. How do the minds work to make a love story out of something like that?
Thu 14/02/02 at 16:38
Regular
Posts: 23,216
MoJoJoJo wrote:

"How do you KNOW that? How do you KNOW that the film is going to do that?"

We don't KNOW, but it's a really good guess. Is a game released to tie in with a film, you think, going to be any good? It's the same thing, they're just throwing merchendise off a tradegy, and they'll call it a love story to get all the mong people with no idea what life's about so they can make a bundle of cash before we even forget about what's going on.

But hey, it's not as if there's anything better to make a movie about. Not such as the fighter squadron of black men, who were refused to serve in World War 2, who then eventually became the best squadron in the war, and even painted their planes a different colour because they were so proud.

Hell, throw a love story in, and I'll start work on the t-shirts.
Thu 14/02/02 at 16:33
Regular
"Excommunicated"
Posts: 23,284
Hmmm

Well I certainly won't be going to see it.

Sounding cynical but I'm not surprised... it's like Pandora's Box for the money hungry swines.
Thu 14/02/02 at 16:31
Regular
"That's right!"
Posts: 10,645
"This is not entertainment, this is not showing the bravery of people.
This is Hollywood making money out of pain and loss and suffering."

----------------------

How do you KNOW that? How do you KNOW that the film is going to do that? It could be handled well and actually be a good, thought provoking film

Then again, of course, you could be right and it will be terrible, but at least reserve judgement until you know more about it
Thu 14/02/02 at 15:35
Regular
Posts: 23,216
Unrespectful, lazy, and just damn disgusting. This isn't about remembering loss so much, it was a disaster, and we can't slam everything that reminds us of it.

But this is just a lazy attempt to make people feel "emotional" at a film. And what's more, it's only just funning happened.

I'm with Goatboy here, this is disgusting.
Thu 14/02/02 at 13:43
Regular
"Back in black"
Posts: 5,486
It is shameful, but in todays twisted world... money is all that matters, shame!
Thu 14/02/02 at 13:22
Regular
"Infantalised Forums"
Posts: 23,089
Ok, to understand why I'm so angry, think of it like this.

5 months ago your brother/mother/uncle was killed in a terrorist attack.
Now they're making a film about it.

Events that affected you directly are now being turned into a glossy hollywood movie.
Except you know that the bit where your relative was obliterated so badly they could only find some bits of that person isn't going to shown.

Instead, it's a couple of beautiful people pretending they know what that feels like.

They won't show the pain and loss and phone calls at 2am from the person left behind to cope on their own.
They won't show the aching loss that person feels and the contemplation of suicide because the reason you feel special is dead, torn to pieces.
Instead, this is being turned into a love story.

I'm out of here.
Thu 14/02/02 at 13:20
Regular
"Wants Spymate on dv"
Posts: 3,025
Just noticed, MoJoJoJo said practically the same thing.

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

The coolest ISP ever!
In my opinion, the ISP is the best I have ever used. They guarantee 'first time connection - everytime', which they have never let me down on.
I am delighted.
Brilliant! As usual the careful and intuitive production that Freeola puts into everything it sets out to do. I am delighted.

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.