Viewing Thread:
"NFL 2004, WWE XIX or Gladius?"

Reviews would help for any of these games? Which should I get?

What I didn't get is that at some point in the review of WWE XIX it said that if the game didn't improve once it was finished it wouldn't be worth buying. So they reviewed the game but it still wasn't finished?

If a game doesn't compare to No Mercy, it doesn't get a good score in NGC. Even if it is actually rather good.

When comparing to other reviews, NGC's 68% seems a little harsh.

Strange, NGC gave it quite a low mark. About the 60% range I think it was. You might want to check out who reviewed it though as NGC seems to be changing staff like the wind lately.

Also N64 magazine (old NGC magazine) rated WCW Vs NWO revenge quite low and that game was fantastic.

Early reviews of Wrestlemania XIX are good; NOM gave it 87 or 89%.

If I was only allowed one game on my GC, I woulf definitely choose Madden [2004]

Personally, if I had just one GameCube game, and was told I could buy one of those three - and out of those three only. I'd save my money.

Get Madden 2004 if your into American Football.

2003 was Ace.

in MY oppinion all those games are pretty crap but thats my pointless oppinion heh.

also, i've never got "GAD" before, i'm not wise enough :P

NGC gave Madden 2004 87%, which is a good score, especially from them.

So I claimed it for my GAD. w00t w00t.

Magazine scores of NFL 2004 have been in the 60% region saying nothing has changed from last years. The Xbox version of Gladius is utter ballax and really is poorly executed in every possible way. Official Nintendo mag gave Wrestlemania 67% I believe and I have seen another for 62% around gamerankings somewhere. No blanket statement at all. The games are pretty average by the sounds of it so why not wait and buy something thats going to be really good?