The "General Games Chat" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.
Example:
Grand Theft Auto 3
v
Jak 2
and if you think that Jak 2 is better then you do this:
Grand Theft Auto 3
v
Jak 2 (Yes)
You have to pick one from each round and the closing time is midnight tommorow. (Friday 23rd April.) I will then count up the votes and then there will be another knock-out round with 8 teams in it and so on until we have a game that we can call 'THE BEST PS2 GAME EVER'!!!
These are the choices:
Grand Theft Auto 3
v
Final Fantasy X
Pro Evolution Soccer 3
v
Ico
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
v
Soul Calibur 2
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
v
Deus Ex
Devil May Cry
v
Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec
JAK 2
v
James Bond 007: Everything or Nothing
SSX 3
v
Tony Hawk's Underground
Medal of Honor: Frontline
v
Splinter Cell
Get voting!
That makes me biased against it, and makes me thinkt hat other ps2 games are better.
Anyway, I demand you all go and buy Beyond Good And Evil NOW!!!
It rocks. I just finished sneaking around the shadows in the factory, some bits of this game just feel hard, and the stealth sections are good, it genuinely feels easier to hide than to fight, which makes a nice change.
> But while we're on the subject, I was surprised that Ico was pitted
> against PES3, and Deus Ex against Vice City, when all four deserve
> higher than the first round.
Sorry but I drew the names out of a hat.
> FFX and GTA3 both deserve to be in a shortlist ahead of Deus X, SSX 3
> and THUG, so why compare two games from a completely different
> genre?
Hah. Deus Ex is better than both of those games.
But while we're on the subject, I was surprised that Ico was pitted against PES3, and Deus Ex against Vice City, when all four deserve higher than the first round.
> This is stupid :D
>
> FFX and GTA3 both deserve to be in a shortlist ahead of Deus X, SSX 3
> and THUG, so why compare two games from a completely different
> genre?
FFX and GTA 3 are both in it.
> That list is also missing Beyond Good And Evil, which I would say is
> JUST AS GOOD as Metal Gear Solid 2.
I obviously can't please everyone as everyone has a different taste in games.
FFX and GTA3 both deserve to be in a shortlist ahead of Deus X, SSX 3 and THUG, so why compare two games from a completely different genre?
If you want to find out the best game, take a straight poll and find out what the people wha actually play games think.
That list is also missing Beyond Good And Evil, which I would say is JUST AS GOOD as Metal Gear Solid 2.
> Hey THE MADMAN, Where are your answers?
the ones on the top sorry i didnt understand
so
GTA: Vice city
v
Jak2
vice city would be my choice.
Grand Theft Auto 3
v
Final Fantasy X
Pro Evolution Soccer 3
v
Ico
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
V
Soul Calibur 2
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
v
Deus Ex
Devil May Cry
v
Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec
Jak 2
v
James Bond 007: Everything or Nothing
SSX 3
v
Tony Hawk's Underground
Medal of Honor: Frontline
v
Splinter Cell
>
> Grand Theft Auto 3
> v
> Final Fantasy X(Yes)
>
> Pro Evolution Soccer 3
> v
> Ico(Yes)
>
> Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty(Yes)
> v
> Soul Calibur 2
>
> Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
> v
> Deus Ex(Yes)
>
> Devil May Cry
> v
> Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec(Yes)
>
> JAK 2
> v
> James Bond 007: Everything or Nothing(Yes)
>
> SSX 3(Yes)
> v
> Tony Hawk's Underground
>
> Medal of Honor: Frontline
> v
> Splinter Cell(Yes)