GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"Mobile phones and US TV shows"

The "Freeola Customer Forum" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Sat 20/03/04 at 01:00
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
No doubt you've guessed roughly what's coming...

I've just been watching an old episode of The X Files on BBC2, which showed Mulder in an old box-car railway carriage. Metal, of course. And buried out in the desert, in the middle of nowhere. The only way out is a small hatch in the roof.

And he's talking to Scully on his mobile. He only gets cut off when the hatch is closed!

Wha...?

I go into the local bus station and I can't get a signal, let alone being in the middle of nowhere and/or buried in a metal box... so how does that work?

And how come, in practically every US show (that features such a scene), it appears that you can use your mobile freely in hospitals?

Is this just a convenience thing for TV, or is there something fundamentally different about the way US mobiles work?
Sat 20/03/04 at 16:16
Regular
"leaf it aaaaht"
Posts: 7,914
If someone uses their mobile phone in Casulty then the nearest nurse tells them to turn it off..maybe it's just the Americans!
Sat 20/03/04 at 16:09
Regular
"Pouch Ape"
Posts: 14,499
Some types of transmission do use reflective surfaces to boost the strength of the carrier waves, so things like buildings, adverse weather and even being in enclosed structures can help with the signal.

I'm a good boy in class.
Sat 20/03/04 at 11:33
"I love yo... lamp."
Posts: 19,577
Actually, the majority of US mobile phones do work on a different technology, CDMA as opposed to the GSM used everywhere else.

But it would still interfere with hospital equipment. Which is why in 24 series 1 Jack Bauer was told off for using his.

Shame you get such bad signal, I can use my phone in Glasgow's Subway. And they don't have aerials down there. Go me.
Sat 20/03/04 at 11:09
Regular
"Lisan al-Gaib"
Posts: 7,093
I just love now that *every* horror movie has to have a broken cellphone / battery dead / no signal moment.

What I'd love to see is a movie where the busty teen is hiding from the chainsaw weilding lunatic, and the phone bleeps as she gets a text message.

Bwhahahahaha.
Sat 20/03/04 at 08:42
Regular
"Hellfire Stoker"
Posts: 10,534
I think it's just there for the dramatic reasons. Using a mobile phone in a hospital is a very stupid thing to do seeing as the signals disrupt various pieces of machinery. And even the dumbest American surely knows that...
Sat 20/03/04 at 01:51
Regular
Posts: 15,579
Heh, i noticed that too.

I really have no answer, but...

I'm sure i've seen this episode before, but i cant remember how the hell mulder gets out of this one! I mean, he was quite clearly trapped in there when the door was shut and surely must have been burnt alive!

Guess i'll just have to wait till next week...
Sat 20/03/04 at 01:48
Regular
"Which one's pink?"
Posts: 12,152
Heh, I see what you mean.

But concerning the hospital thing, yeah, it's true, but in hospital specific shows, eg ER, that's not seen. So that's a good thing I suppose.


[S][S]ER's the only example I can think of...[/S][/S]
Sat 20/03/04 at 01:00
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
No doubt you've guessed roughly what's coming...

I've just been watching an old episode of The X Files on BBC2, which showed Mulder in an old box-car railway carriage. Metal, of course. And buried out in the desert, in the middle of nowhere. The only way out is a small hatch in the roof.

And he's talking to Scully on his mobile. He only gets cut off when the hatch is closed!

Wha...?

I go into the local bus station and I can't get a signal, let alone being in the middle of nowhere and/or buried in a metal box... so how does that work?

And how come, in practically every US show (that features such a scene), it appears that you can use your mobile freely in hospitals?

Is this just a convenience thing for TV, or is there something fundamentally different about the way US mobiles work?

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

Continue this excellent work...
Brilliant! As usual the careful and intuitive production that Freeola puts into everything it sets out to do, I am delighted.
Easy and free service!
I think it's fab that you provide an easy-to-follow service, and even better that it's free...!
Cerrie

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.