Viewing Thread:
"Is it possible to..."

win a GAD in a replying post rather than an the actual subject post? I mean, if it was a really good, informative etc etc point about the subject or something? Just wondering, because it never seems to happen.

Ahhhhh FAD

I remember one topic in particular won GAD with the original post then someone replied and won GAD with that, we named that the lucky topic obviously ;)

Yes it is, there was a girl called Kitty who used to post in movies a lot, and she won with a couple of replies if I remember.

That was back in the day.
(when movies had there own prize)
Boy, those were the days.

*reminisces nostalgicallly.

gerrid wrote:
> I asked SR the same question, and apparently, RM18 won with a reply
> once, but he's the only one I know of.

There was a spate of replies winning GAD a while back (6-12 months ago)...

I suppose it just depends on the quality of the repl...

Most posts seem to get a couple of short replies beofre it moves off subject?

I asked SR the same question, and apparently, RM18 won with a reply once, but he's the only one I know of.

Yeah, but it's rare. Last time it happened was last years sometime, I think.

I don't really care though.

Theres an example in the archives, me thinks it was 1/2pint.

Jericho15 wrote:
> That was a good quesion, I never knew that!
>
> :-)

What, are sure you really didn't? I knew that after a couple of days coming here.

Kewl!

;)

That was a good quesion, I never knew that!

:-)

Cyclone wrote:
> win a GAD in a replying post rather than an the actual subject post? I
> mean, if it was a really good, informative etc etc point about the
> subject or something? Just wondering, because it never seems to
> happen.

They've always been the "original" post for a topic.