The "General Games Chat" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.
Here's the all-time top 40 games as voted for by gamers.
(Ratings in % are compiled by readers' reviews score).
1. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo N64 98.9%
2. Half-Life Sierra Studios PC 97.2%
3. Soul Calibur Namco DC 97.0%
4. Metal Gear Solid 2 Konami PS2 96.1%
5. Grand Theft Auto III Rockstar Games PS2 96.1%
6. Goldeneye Nintendo N64 96.0%
7. Super Mario 64 Nintendo N64 95.8%
8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision PSX 95.6%
9. NFL 2K1 Sega DC 95.6%
10. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision DC 95.5%
11. Perfect Dark Nintendo N64 95.5%
12. Tekken 3 Namco PSX 95.4%
13. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Activision PS2 95.3%
14. Chrono Cross Square Electronic Arts PSX 95.1%
15. Gran Turismo Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.9%
16. Halo Microsoft XBox 94.8%
17. Metal Gear Solid Konami GBC 94.6%
18. Zelda: Oracle of Ages Nintendo GBC 94.6%
19. Unreal Tournament GT Interactive PC 94.5%
20. Final Fantasy VII Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.3%
21. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec Sony Computer Ent. PS2 94.2%
22. Baldur's Gate II Interplay PC 94.0%
23. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Nintendo N64 93.7%
24. Metal Gear Solid Konami PSX 93.6%
25. Resident Evil 2 Capcom Entertainment PSX 93.6%
26. Star Wars: Jedi Knight Lucas Arts PC 93.6%
27. Wipeout XL Psygnosis PSX 93.4%
28. Resident Evil Code: Veronica Capcom Entertainment DC 93.4%
29. Zelda: Oracle of Seasons Nintendo GBC 93.3%
30. Virtua Fighter 4 Sega PS2 93.2%
31. Final Fantasy IX Square Electronic Arts PSX 93.2%
32. Super Smash Bros. Melee Nintendo NGC 93.1%
33. Final Fantasy X Square Electronic Arts PS2 92.9%
34. Starcraft Blizzard PC 92.9%
35. SSX EA Sports PS2 92.9%
36. Rayman 2: The Great Escape UBI Soft DC 92.8%
37. Advance Wars Nintendo GBA 92.8%
38. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Activision PSX 92.8%
39. NFL 2K Sega DC 92.7%
40. Civilization 2 Microprose PC 92.7%
If anyone wants to do some number crunching by position/score to see who the most successful developer/platform etc. is feel free, I'm not going to do it, im tired and headin for bed
(Ratings in % are compiled by readers' reviews score).
1. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo N64 98.9%
2. Half-Life Sierra Studios PC 97.2%
3. Soul Calibur Namco DC 97.0%
4. Metal Gear Solid 2 Konami PS2 96.1%
5. Grand Theft Auto III Rockstar Games PS2 96.1%
6. Goldeneye Nintendo N64 96.0%
7. Super Mario 64 Nintendo N64 95.8%
8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision PSX 95.6%
9. NFL 2K1 Sega DC 95.6%
10. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision DC 95.5%
11. Perfect Dark Nintendo N64 95.5%
12. Tekken 3 Namco PSX 95.4%
13. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Activision PS2 95.3%
14. Chrono Cross Square Electronic Arts PSX 95.1%
15. Gran Turismo Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.9%
16. Halo Microsoft XBox 94.8%
17. Metal Gear Solid Konami GBC 94.6%
18. Zelda: Oracle of Ages Nintendo GBC 94.6%
19. Unreal Tournament GT Interactive PC 94.5%
20. Final Fantasy VII Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.3%
21. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec Sony Computer Ent. PS2 94.2%
22. Baldur's Gate II Interplay PC 94.0%
23. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Nintendo N64 93.7%
24. Metal Gear Solid Konami PSX 93.6%
25. Resident Evil 2 Capcom Entertainment PSX 93.6%
26. Star Wars: Jedi Knight Lucas Arts PC 93.6%
27. Wipeout XL Psygnosis PSX 93.4%
28. Resident Evil Code: Veronica Capcom Entertainment DC 93.4%
29. Zelda: Oracle of Seasons Nintendo GBC 93.3%
30. Virtua Fighter 4 Sega PS2 93.2%
31. Final Fantasy IX Square Electronic Arts PSX 93.2%
32. Super Smash Bros. Melee Nintendo NGC 93.1%
33. Final Fantasy X Square Electronic Arts PS2 92.9%
34. Starcraft Blizzard PC 92.9%
35. SSX EA Sports PS2 92.9%
36. Rayman 2: The Great Escape UBI Soft DC 92.8%
37. Advance Wars Nintendo GBA 92.8%
38. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Activision PSX 92.8%
39. NFL 2K Sega DC 92.7%
40. Civilization 2 Microprose PC 92.7%
If anyone wants to do some number crunching by position/score to see who the most successful developer/platform etc. is feel free, I'm not going to do it, im tired and headin for bed
There have been no replies to this thread yet.
Here's the all-time top 40 games as voted for by gamers.
(Ratings in % are compiled by readers' reviews score).
1. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo N64 98.9%
2. Half-Life Sierra Studios PC 97.2%
3. Soul Calibur Namco DC 97.0%
4. Metal Gear Solid 2 Konami PS2 96.1%
5. Grand Theft Auto III Rockstar Games PS2 96.1%
6. Goldeneye Nintendo N64 96.0%
7. Super Mario 64 Nintendo N64 95.8%
8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision PSX 95.6%
9. NFL 2K1 Sega DC 95.6%
10. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision DC 95.5%
11. Perfect Dark Nintendo N64 95.5%
12. Tekken 3 Namco PSX 95.4%
13. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Activision PS2 95.3%
14. Chrono Cross Square Electronic Arts PSX 95.1%
15. Gran Turismo Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.9%
16. Halo Microsoft XBox 94.8%
17. Metal Gear Solid Konami GBC 94.6%
18. Zelda: Oracle of Ages Nintendo GBC 94.6%
19. Unreal Tournament GT Interactive PC 94.5%
20. Final Fantasy VII Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.3%
21. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec Sony Computer Ent. PS2 94.2%
22. Baldur's Gate II Interplay PC 94.0%
23. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Nintendo N64 93.7%
24. Metal Gear Solid Konami PSX 93.6%
25. Resident Evil 2 Capcom Entertainment PSX 93.6%
26. Star Wars: Jedi Knight Lucas Arts PC 93.6%
27. Wipeout XL Psygnosis PSX 93.4%
28. Resident Evil Code: Veronica Capcom Entertainment DC 93.4%
29. Zelda: Oracle of Seasons Nintendo GBC 93.3%
30. Virtua Fighter 4 Sega PS2 93.2%
31. Final Fantasy IX Square Electronic Arts PSX 93.2%
32. Super Smash Bros. Melee Nintendo NGC 93.1%
33. Final Fantasy X Square Electronic Arts PS2 92.9%
34. Starcraft Blizzard PC 92.9%
35. SSX EA Sports PS2 92.9%
36. Rayman 2: The Great Escape UBI Soft DC 92.8%
37. Advance Wars Nintendo GBA 92.8%
38. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Activision PSX 92.8%
39. NFL 2K Sega DC 92.7%
40. Civilization 2 Microprose PC 92.7%
If anyone wants to do some number crunching by position/score to see who the most successful developer/platform etc. is feel free, I'm not going to do it, im tired and headin for bed
(Ratings in % are compiled by readers' reviews score).
1. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo N64 98.9%
2. Half-Life Sierra Studios PC 97.2%
3. Soul Calibur Namco DC 97.0%
4. Metal Gear Solid 2 Konami PS2 96.1%
5. Grand Theft Auto III Rockstar Games PS2 96.1%
6. Goldeneye Nintendo N64 96.0%
7. Super Mario 64 Nintendo N64 95.8%
8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision PSX 95.6%
9. NFL 2K1 Sega DC 95.6%
10. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 Activision DC 95.5%
11. Perfect Dark Nintendo N64 95.5%
12. Tekken 3 Namco PSX 95.4%
13. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Activision PS2 95.3%
14. Chrono Cross Square Electronic Arts PSX 95.1%
15. Gran Turismo Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.9%
16. Halo Microsoft XBox 94.8%
17. Metal Gear Solid Konami GBC 94.6%
18. Zelda: Oracle of Ages Nintendo GBC 94.6%
19. Unreal Tournament GT Interactive PC 94.5%
20. Final Fantasy VII Sony Computer Ent. PSX 94.3%
21. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec Sony Computer Ent. PS2 94.2%
22. Baldur's Gate II Interplay PC 94.0%
23. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Nintendo N64 93.7%
24. Metal Gear Solid Konami PSX 93.6%
25. Resident Evil 2 Capcom Entertainment PSX 93.6%
26. Star Wars: Jedi Knight Lucas Arts PC 93.6%
27. Wipeout XL Psygnosis PSX 93.4%
28. Resident Evil Code: Veronica Capcom Entertainment DC 93.4%
29. Zelda: Oracle of Seasons Nintendo GBC 93.3%
30. Virtua Fighter 4 Sega PS2 93.2%
31. Final Fantasy IX Square Electronic Arts PSX 93.2%
32. Super Smash Bros. Melee Nintendo NGC 93.1%
33. Final Fantasy X Square Electronic Arts PS2 92.9%
34. Starcraft Blizzard PC 92.9%
35. SSX EA Sports PS2 92.9%
36. Rayman 2: The Great Escape UBI Soft DC 92.8%
37. Advance Wars Nintendo GBA 92.8%
38. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Activision PSX 92.8%
39. NFL 2K Sega DC 92.7%
40. Civilization 2 Microprose PC 92.7%
If anyone wants to do some number crunching by position/score to see who the most successful developer/platform etc. is feel free, I'm not going to do it, im tired and headin for bed