Viewing Thread:
"I need your opinion"

Which of the two versions of the tune on my MIDI site do you like best?

http://www.geocities.com/cheatser2/doughnuts_midifiles.html

Please tell me!

I composed them myself and I would like some feedback.

Cheers

Grix Thraves wrote:
> I love the use of the 'test card' noise at the end of the second.
>
> In my opinion, they're both fantastic.

Thanks I'm glad you liked it.

It's actually meant to be Thunder! the sound at the end of the second

FantasyMeister wrote:
> First one is better. The second one sounds like you started the melody
> in a different bar to the accompanyment in places, although the
> arrangement is more like the original by the Animals. But a kazoo as
> the lead? Nah.

Welll I don't know much about music but the background was fairly hard to do.
took over an hour to get right.

It's a trumpet actually.

It sounds better using WinAmp.

filename

I hope that helps.

No space before Filename

I love the use of the 'test card' noise at the end of the second.

In my opinion, they're both fantastic.

How do you upload MIDI files to a GEOCITIES account?

First one is better. The second one sounds like you started the melody in a different bar to the accompanyment in places, although the arrangement is more like the original by the Animals. But a kazoo as the lead? Nah.

Wouldn't it be more logical to just fix the website?

I just can't load the V2 link, which links to the first one [filewise]. Get a page not found thingy.

I can almost guarantee the second one is better!

What's your MSN adress?
I'll e-mail the file to you!

Grix Thraves wrote:
> LOL
>
> The first one is fantastic! Can't load the second one... damn! Midi
> rules.



Tell me exactly what comes up!
I'll try and fix it?
Or is it just slow loading?

LOL

The first one is fantastic! Can't load the second one... damn! Midi rules.