Viewing Thread:
"Star Wars , Star Trek or Stargate : Which is the best?"

Star Trek is alright the latest Star Trek movies are satisfactory.Stargate the original film was good and the first series of sg1 are quite interesting. The best of those three sci fi cults have to be Star wars its quality. The best Star Trek series has to be Enterprise and the best Starwars movie has to be A new hope.

What level are they all being judged on? I pressume sicne Star Wars is in the list we are debating the best Movies. However which Star Wars one and which Star Trek one? I still think the Stargate movie would win ouut of that though. Or are we including t.v. series? If so which Star Trek one? I must admit I watch an equal amount of Star Trek Voyager to Stargate: SG-1. Prefer Stargate SG-1 though although repeats can become very tedious, less so than Star Trek Voyager in my opinion. However is we are including T.V. shows that puts star wars at a disadvantage.

I think I'd have to say that Stargate SG-1, out of all the t.v. show and movie possibilities would be the one I would watch. It is a brilliant idea with limitless possibilities and I definitely think it's got a few more series in it too. Maybe even as many as F.R.I.E.N.D.S, I hope so anyway because it is just getting better and better and if we keep advancing in it at the rate we are then it'll soon be like Star Trek anyway:P

Since when was Star Trek supposed to be a comedy?

Icaruss wrote:
> Stargate is the best by far, you can't put a price on the humour of
> Colenel Jack O'Neill - with two "L"s!

Yes Stargate SG1 is by far the best, it's outlived all the 7 series end of program limit and even spawed 2 spinoffs, even though the cartoon failed to meet expectations after it's first year.
Oh and Jack's humour is by far way better than any of the star trek character's i've seen.

Voyager, when Harlon Ellison ("I have no mouth, but I must scream") got involved as a consultant. Some good, "hard" SF storylines.

I just find the Star Trek Next Generation or DS9 boring it just doesn't have that thing to make me watch it. Its not enough going on and slow paced.

Stargate is the best by far, you can't put a price on the humour of Colenel Jack O'Neill - with two "L"s!

Oh and yes, what I managed to miss out was that Star Trek is the best by far. Simply because it created a whole universe without it just being a terribly milked cash cow. Sure, there are millions of books and games and memorabilia, but there is also 30 or so seasons over 6 series and 10 movies to base them on. Compare that to just 5 movies.

The only thing that Star Wars really has going for it is light sabres.

Yeah it was strange. Voyager didn't give quite the same feeling because it had a final fulfillment at the end, in that they got home.

The Next Generation also had the DS9 feeling in the way it ended. It's going to be worse when Frasier ends.

I was genuinely sad when watching the last episode of DS9. It was like something massive had ended for me.

Spaceballs yay!

To go into more detail I'd say DS9 is my favourite and Next:Gen and Babylon 5 just miss out.