GetDotted Domains

Viewing Thread:
"XBOX HAS WON THE BATTLE!!!"

The "Sony Games" forum, which includes Retro Game Reviews, has been archived and is now read-only. You cannot post here or create a new thread or review on this forum.

Tue 16/01/01 at 11:07
Regular
Posts: 787
Hi all. Now I am on your side, and am not against an company..but the fact of the matter is XBOX has released a monster of a console which makes PS2 look very weak.
XBOX CPU= 733MHz, 150 million polygons/s
PS2 CPU = 294MHz, 20 million polygons/s, which is still impressive, but compared to XBOX...
and this is just a breif of advantages XBOX had...
And the shipping problem of PS2 hasnt helped. This is just what XBOX could of hoped for, as people get mad as they cant get a PS2, and will wait for the XBOX. So sorry SONY, but it seems like whatever Microsoft touches becomes GOLD, and you have had your turn...Its Microsofts NOW!!!
Wed 17/01/01 at 08:54
Regular
"not dead"
Posts: 11,145
kieran0601 wrote:

>It is indeed a powerful machine.

So powerful, in fact that it overheats, that's why it's in such a chunky casing, and the Japanese think it is too big to fit in nicely with their living rooms.


meka_dragon PQMS8/00
Wed 17/01/01 at 09:19
Posts: 0
yeah I heard that too; just how BIG is this thing?

still it does come from the land of the free....god bless america; they were the first to do everything ever and they're the best at everything and every hero there ever was must have been an american and bigger is better and they don't have deep rooted social and handgun problems at all.

oops did I just say that?
Wed 17/01/01 at 09:45
Posts: 0
Hi again...now guyz..everyone of you has a good point.
I also agree with what you are saying...BUT the fact is..XBOX is much more powerfull than the PS2....dAlthough MHz is not that important...look at the polygons it can produce..GRAPHICS = POLYGONS....
And please be honest..when you play PS2, you will notice that it's not really that POWERFUL!! All the hype has made people wanna buy it..but when u get it..u think..okay, theres a few less rough egdes..but its NOT a huge leap from the PSX and N64. However the XBOX will do 150Million polygons/s...That means the graphics will be XTREMELY GOOD!! And you will notice a huge diffrence in terms of graphics, speed(MHz), and power.
And whats this about no games!!!!!!
Have you not heard anything???
Metal Gear X is in development, Final Fantasy 10 is in development, and over 100 devleopers have gone with XBOX!!
But however, i do agree, it will be a while before it comes..so enjoy your PS2 while its here.
PS: The GAMECUBE will give XBOX a hard ride.
Wed 17/01/01 at 10:01
Regular
"Complete Banker"
Posts: 562
I don't think it's as claer cut as many people seem to think.
Ok so the PS2 was over-hyped, but I'm not disappointed. And also one of the major strengths of the PSOne was the fact that it evolved over the last 5 years into someting much more than what it was originally. A prime example is Ridge Racer to RR4, or Tomb Raider to TR: Chronicles.
This will be true on the PS2 aswell.
The Mhz is a false indicator, it is true that the PsOne had a 33Mhz processor and could keep up with a PC 10 times faster. This is because the arcitecture in the PSOne and PS2 is very specialised and efficient, whereas the PC (and X-Box) is out dated and slow. So even though the X-Box has a 400 (or so) Mhz processor it doesn't make it that much more powerful.
Also the Polygon-per-second claim is exactly that - a claim.
Sony orininally stated 75m pps, and no one can get very close and I suspect that the X-Box will be the same.

Overall they are both very competent machines and the 'War' will be a very close fought 'battle'. I wouldn't like to call it, but it depends on how well accepted the X-box is - especially in Japan and how soon sony can come up with some killer titles!
Wed 17/01/01 at 10:06
Posts: 0
Ok; well, just to re-impress anyone who has lost faith in PS2; check out the Ace Combat 4 quicktime movie at:

www.ps2web.com

Anyone have doubts now?

Even talking about polygons, you can make figures up....

these 150million or whatever that x-box can do; are these rendered? are the light sources and shading in place when they count them? are they meaningful, moving polygononal objects or simply one static triangle at a time?

Sony went through all this when they were developing ps2, quoting all sorts of numbers; but a lot of it doesn't immediately translate into the best gaming experience of all time (refer to ps2 launch games)!

So, xbox, gamecube and ps2 lovers all, please don't listen to the numbers.....wait until you see real life performance.

Can anyone honestly believe that Sony are the only people EVER to hype a product, or that Microsoft has such a perfect morality that it would only tell the bare, unbiased truth?

haha.


Wed 17/01/01 at 11:29
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
> Metal Gear X is in development

Which is not MGS2, but an enhances MGS1.


> Final Fantasy 10 is in development

As it is for PS2.


> and over 100 devleopers have gone with
> XBOX!!

Few of which are exclusive - they will also be developing for other platforms, so MS aren't exactly stealing developers from other platforms. And since you mentioned it, Sony have over 300 developers.
Wed 17/01/01 at 13:30
Regular
Posts: 15,579
ps2 is having a rough ride. the damn thing cant even hit 20 million polygons a sec. it aint even hitting 10 at the moment is it. i can see n64 style problems coming on here. i mean look at gt3. its been delayed. surly its down to the fact its hell to program for. same problem as the 64.

And end of the day gamecube games will take half the time to produce games for. so i think that is the point.,
Wed 17/01/01 at 13:49
"High polygon count"
Posts: 15,624
> ps2 is having a rough ride. the damn thing cant even hit 20 million
> polygons a sec. it aint even hitting 10 at the moment is it.

GT3 - 20 million polys/sec, and that's with a lot of the EE's power being used for driver AI.


> i mean look at gt3. its been
> delayed. surly its down to the fact its hell to program for.

Incorrect assumption. The game is pretty much complete, and the extra time is for fine-tuning.


> And end of the day gamecube games will
> take half the time to produce games for.

Maybe, but as people get used to the quirks of the machine, production times will fall. Even so, developers aren't likely to give up on PS2.


> so i think that is the point.

The point of what, exactly? Nintendo aren't intending to compete with PS2 or X-Box, and have said so themselves.
Wed 17/01/01 at 19:37
Regular
Posts: 15,579
has gt3 been released yet? no i dont think so shut the hell up. trust, this game wont be out here for ages.
so if nintendo arnt competing with x box and ps2 who are they competing with? they aint exatcly gonna say out load that are trying their hardest to beat microsoft and sony. cos if they lose they would have to eat those words.
Wed 17/01/01 at 23:44
Regular
Posts: 6,702
May your Tambogiri be a passage to hell!
(Thats as close as I can get to quoting Honda from Kessen).
Don`t know what a Tambogiri is, but I`m guessing it could be a cross between a tampon and a toilet (bog) with a Japanese twisty thing on the end. Either that or it could be that violin thingy the commanders wave around when they send the soldiers of to die. Either way I very much doubt it has anything to do with the topic under discussion here!

Freeola & GetDotted are rated 5 Stars

Check out some of our customer reviews below:

Brilliant service.
Love it, love it, love it!
Christopher
LOVE it....
You have made it so easy to build & host a website!!!
Gemma

View More Reviews

Need some help? Give us a call on 01376 55 60 60

Go to Support Centre
Feedback Close Feedback

It appears you are using an old browser, as such, some parts of the Freeola and Getdotted site will not work as intended. Using the latest version of your browser, or another browser such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Opera will provide a better, safer browsing experience for you.